Read transcriptHide transcript
[0:00] Why you've got everyone freaking out
about the release of GTA six.
[0:03] Diving into the good bad and problems
that have gotten
[0:05] the Roblox
predator situation has gotten so crazy.
[0:07] You have YouTubers
speaking in front of Congress
[0:09] where Paris Hilton is joining forces
with AOC to take down AI deepfake meta.
[0:13] Build a school program that said
it was to protect kids from bullying.
[0:15] But internal documents revealed that it's
designed to get them hooked on
[0:18] and in addition to our new bestselling
drop a Beautiful Bastard,
[0:21] you can get premium blanks for 50% off
about we're talking
[0:24] about all of that and even more on today's
brand new Philip DeFranco show.
[0:28] You daily dive into the news
starting with GTA six is finally here
[0:32] and everyone is losing their damn minds
in both good and bad ways.
[0:35] We'll start with the release itself.
[0:36] that's because GTA six, it's technically
not getting released until midnight
[0:40] local time
everywhere in the world on November 19th.
[0:42] It's supposed to be region
time zone locked.
[0:44] And so you've got some gamers
and even streamers risking account
[0:46] suspensions and bands
[0:47] to be among the first to play the game
using the viral New Zealand
[0:50] because New Zealand's one of the places
that the game is available
[0:52] first
because of the international date line.
[0:54] And so you've got a lot of streamers
and gamers changing their digital location
[0:57] or time zone to say that they're in New
with the idea being to
[0:59] then get access to the game hours
before everyone else in their hemisphere.
[1:02] and this is a trick that some Xbox users
have used for a decade
[1:05] without too much consequence.
[1:06] and that's despite the fact that Xbox's
terms and conditions specifically state
[1:09] trying to circumvent regional content
restrictions is really good.
[1:12] And and breaking
that rule could technically result
[1:13] in account suspension
[1:14] or and you're seeing
a number of people out there
[1:16] recommending against it's saying
that an account suspension is a very real
[1:19] also but then also
[1:20] you've got a lot of people saying,
hey, that's just beer mongering and saying
[1:22] the actual risk is pretty low,
including The Verge editor Tom Warren,
[1:25] taken to Twitter yesterday
[1:26] to say that no one is going to get banned
for changing a console
[1:29] and adding that Xbox knows
that people use the New Zealand
[1:31] trick, and executives
have even made jokes about it in the
[1:33] And they're specifically pointing
to the VP of games marketing at X-Box,
[1:36] Aaron Greenberg's account, where he again
made a joke about the New Zealand then.
[1:39] But then as far as Sony,
maybe a different right.
[1:42] The PlayStation, in terms of service,
requires players
[1:43] to register their account in their country
or region of residence and can restrict
[1:47] accounts created with false with that
and with that,
[1:49] you've got some unverified
claims swirling online
[1:51] that people have gotten their accounts
banned on their site.
[1:53] So we're trying the New But but really
the biggest risk would be if you stream
[1:56] right now, that several German streamers
warning that Twitch is coming down
[1:59] hard on those trying to work around
[2:00] the one
[2:00] with one saying
[2:01] that a switch partner manager informed him
of a possible ban on his account because
[2:04] but then also with that,
[2:05] like if you think about it,
it makes sense for a lot of streamers
[2:07] to take this risk
in order to get to the game Right? Right.
[2:09] So you've got streamers like xQc
[2:11] using the The New Zealand
trick to be one of the first to stream
[2:13] the game to his audience, saying that
he doesn't play it as soon as he can.
[2:16] The chat on a stream,
just going to spoil the game also,
[2:18] and then you also have other big creators
like I show Speed and Kaizen
[2:20] saying that they're actually
in New Zealand right now
[2:22] so they can play the again,
[2:23] but again,
for everyone on this side of the world
[2:24] not willing to risk account suspension
[2:26] or taking the extra steps
that the game drops tonight the release
[2:28] and with the release,
you've got some bracing for Right.
[2:31] Right in that in part
because of this report
[2:32] from the International Business
Times claiming
[2:34] that the launch could cost
the United States $1
[2:36] just just simply from people
planning on skipping work right with that.
[2:39] Right.
[2:39] And with that, you had an economics
professor at the University of Barcelona
[2:42] claiming that there will be
[2:42] 1.5 million Americans
calling out sick or taking vacation
[2:45] or just not being at work tomorrow
to play GTA And so and so we
[2:48] then multiply that by an estimated average
yearly output of about $70,000 per US
[2:52] and they concluded that nearly $1 billion
will be drained from America.
[2:55] Total output for the day
because of a lack of
[2:58] they understand
that's not an official forecast.
[3:00] That is what we'll call it, an academic
[3:02] and in fact,
there's been a lot of pushback to that,
[3:04] including from other economists
who say that even if that's they
[3:07] they say it's shortsighted
and it doesn't look at the
[3:10] or with Victor Matheson, for example,
an economist
[3:11] at the College of the Holy Cross
who studies
[3:13] sports and major events, telling even
[3:15] even if we did have $1 billion of people
call out sick, that's a short term laws
[3:19] that is made up for in the long term
when that PTO day isn't available for you
[3:22] next February, next March, next June,
next like saying it's not like
[3:25] people are going to take more days off
than in the past
[3:28] because that it's changing
[3:29] when those days are getting then also
but then also there's a conversation
[3:32] about money in the opposite direction,
right? Money Right. Because. Right.
[3:35] Because as of recording, it is believed
that there are more than 17 million units
[3:38] sold so far,
so over $1.65 billion in revenue as Right?
[3:43] That's just the beginning.
[3:44] Rockstar games is reportedly
[3:45] projecting 45 million copies being sold in
just the first year after release,
[3:49] which comes out to more than $3 billion
makes it bigger than any movie launch,
[3:53] bigger than any Taylor Swift or Beyoncé
album, which also it makes sense.
[3:57] has been one of the most anticipated games
for over a decade. hey.
[4:00] So far the reviews are saying
it is worth all this waiting.
[4:03] like, I've never seen an almost
universally praise game like this.
[4:06] IGN called it the single most impressive
video game I've ever played.
[4:09] Gamespot gave it a perfect ten.
[4:11] The Guardian gave it five stars.
[4:13] The reviewer called it Rockstar's
magnum opus and said
[4:16] it may be, quote,
the best open world game of all time.
[4:19] and then on both Metacritic
and Open Critic,
[4:21] there are 99 as of opening, making it
the best reviewed game of all time.
[4:25] but also, it's not all sunshine
and rainbows,
[4:28] there's been pushbacks and critiques.
[4:29] We'll start with some that we've seen
from the more conservative spaces.
[4:32] Right. And so on. Fox and friends, for
example, I felt like we went back in time.
[4:35] They did a quick
look at the preview of the game,
[4:37] and you had some very classic on brand
pearl clutching from Rachel Campos Duffy,
[4:41] the wife of Transportation Secretary
Sean really am going to say I'm not.
[4:45] I'm not thinking this is a good thing
for culture, but in society.
[4:49] But okay, let's see what you think
comes out.
[4:51] You can play in B Lucia.
[4:53] So there's Jason and Lucy.
[4:55] She's a hooker. Lucia.
[4:56] She's a partner in crime. Oh, okay.
[4:58] You can maybe play and get her to go
straight.
[5:01] Change her ways.
[5:02] All right,
And you saw that clip, particularly
[5:04] the bit where she called
one of the main characters a hooker,
[5:06] getting a lot of attention
[5:07] for and for many, you know,
it felt like a classic 2000 shit.
[5:10] Fox News,
you know, going back to their roots.
[5:12] Right? Right.
[5:12] Complaining about this franchise and
video games and their impacts on society.
[5:16] Despite published studies disproving
the video games make kids violent to.
[5:19] Not to mention
[5:20] you had fans of the franchise
saying put some respect on Lucia's name,
[5:23] shouldn't use a seasoned criminal
and a bank robber in also
[5:25] but also on this front
it wasn't just stateside backlash.
[5:27] Or you also had international concern
about the sexual content from South Korean
[5:32] and specifically there,
[5:33] they reportedly had a hard time
settling on a rating for the game,
[5:35] and even came close
to a rating refusal altogether.
[5:37] that and that.
[5:38] Mostly because the game features, quote,
far too much genital
[5:41] And it reportedly took three meetings
to secure an adults only that means so
[5:45] that means that game can proceed. Doors
release in South Korea.
[5:47] But it was definitely a close though
[5:49] interestingly enough, people
who seem most mad at Rockstar Games right
[5:52] now, it's not those
who are scandalized by the game's
[5:55] but rather it's actually people
who are playing or trying to play right.
[5:58] And one of the big hang ups
about this game and many other games
[6:00] is the lack of physical copies
of the game. right.
[6:03] So instead of buying a disk
at your local game store,
[6:04] you'll get an empty case
with the code inside,
[6:06] giving you access
to a digital edition of the game.
[6:08] well, that sparked its own backlash
over the summer.
[6:11] Now you have a lot of people
finding out that their case
[6:12] either has no code inside
or the code's already been used.
[6:16] Meaning they can't access the game,
that they paid a minimum of 80 bucks for.
[6:19] some players and also saying
[6:19] they've been refused replacements
by places like Best Buy at GameStop.
[6:22] So they tried contacting
Rockstar Games for help.
[6:25] but they're you had people saying
it's been crickets with some online saying
[6:28] Rockstar is even closing their tickets
without addressing the problem.
[6:31] as you have many saying,
hey, this is evidence
[6:32] that physical copies of games
are still necessary in the gaming world.
[6:35] also, you've had some people angry
about the frame rate of the game.
[6:37] We're saying 30 frames
per second isn't good enough.
[6:39] Also others saying there have been points
where the frames dropped below that
[6:43] and there have been glitches in the game.
[6:45] then also on top of that
you had some furious
[6:46] that GTA six was nominated
for game of the year
[6:49] before the game came out,
or even any of the reviews went live.
[6:52] you had a number of people claiming
the awards are rigged, saying things like,
[6:55] sure GTA six will be incredible.
[6:56] But the Game Awards is now forever
[6:57] cemented itself as an award show
for a certain click of journos versus
[7:01] the everyday gamer saying
when you nominate a game
[7:03] that no member of the public has even
had the chance
[7:05] to play for game of the year, it's over.
[7:06] then actually speaking of the game awards,
[7:08] there was also a surprise
reveal of the voice
[7:10] actor for one of the game's
main characters, Lucia.
[7:12] because you had Manny Perez
being nominated for Best Performance.
[7:14] while, it's been rumored since 2023
that Perez would be Lucy.
[7:17] His voice.
[7:17] There was no public confirmation
about the cast before the launch.
[7:20] with all that said, hey, I love know
[7:21] your thoughts about this situation,
the game in general, but for me
[7:24] personally, I'm still going to do my job
the very best.
[7:26] I'm going to give you a fantastic Thursday
show tomorrow, but.
[7:30] for the next 72 hours
after that, I'm going to be
[7:32] a little gaming goblin
in my dark little gaming hall.
[7:36] And you know what?
[7:37] Whether it be this game, any game,
no game.
[7:40] Maybe it was going outside
and touching grass.
[7:42] Personally,
I'm going to be going in a whole
[7:43] and touching very expensive digital grass.
[7:45] I want you to know if you haven't
taken one yet, you deserve a little break.
[7:48] There's always the risk of checking out
and never checking back in.
[7:51] But hey, you're going to check back
in. give yourself a little break.
[7:54] The last decade has been fucking insane.
[7:56] Also the last two years have been very,
very crazy in its own right.
[7:59] for many of you watching this show,
[8:01] we are coming off of very good news
post November 3rd.
[8:04] I know you're not dumb.
[8:05] You know that
[8:05] the world is still on fire in many ways,
and there's still a lot of work
[8:08] to be done.
[8:09] please no.
[8:10] Allowing yourself breaks.
[8:11] That is great for the long run.
[8:13] Sprints are a part of it.
[8:14] But change over
the long run is a marathon.
[8:16] you're going to need some breaking breaks
so your brain doesn't go break, break.
[8:20] and it's just important for me,
for you to know that.
[8:22] But then jumping from that to other news.
[8:24] Paris Hilton, AOC
[8:26] and Republican Representative Laura Lee,
they're not the most likely squad.
[8:29] but they do all seem to agree on one
[8:31] Crepes who make and spread non-consensual
deepfake porn should be held accountable.
[8:35] it's a huge problem
that affects everyone, from celebrities
[8:37] to Congress members to everyday people
and even children.
[8:40] and you just had Hilton
[8:40] and the congresswoman
holding a press conference
[8:42] urging House lawmakers
to pass the Defiance
[8:44] which would offer legal recourse
for people
[8:46] whose images get used
in these gross deepfakes.
[8:48] and this is an act that already passed
[8:49] unanimously in the Senate twice,
once in 2024 and once in January of this
[8:53] but all this time
you've had it stalling out in the house,
[8:56] which is why you have supporters
of the legislation
[8:57] speaking a bipartisan coalition
of women and survivors.
[9:02] We demand recourse and restitution
for victims of this crime.
[9:06] Together we are Republicans,
Democrats and independents.
[9:11] But most importantly, we are Americans.
[9:14] And we all agree that women and children
deserve to be protected
[9:19] from sexual exploitation me personally,
[9:22] strangers have created over 100,000
AI generated explicit images
[9:27] and videos portray me in the most graphic
and disturbing ways imaginable, Speaker
[9:31] Johnson, Leader Scalise, and Chairman
Jordan, I am speaking directly to you.
[9:37] Will you
[9:37] allow this to continue
to happen to your colleagues?
[9:41] How about the women and your district?
[9:43] How about your daughters,
your wives, or your sisters?
[9:47] Right with this, as far as you know,
how did Paris Hilton get involved?
[9:49] Why is she on Capitol Hill? Yes.
[9:51] You know, she's known for the simple life
[9:52] being one of the first kind
of reality celebrities.
[9:54] but also, she's fully embraced
the activist lifestyle
[9:57] as someone who's been personally affected
by these issues on multiple right.
[10:00] She's been open about all the explicit
[10:02] AI images and videos of her online
and when she was 19 years old.
[10:05] Of course,
there was an intimate video of her
[10:06] that was shared without her
[10:07] and now she's actually the chief
[10:08] advocacy officer at the digital identity
protection firm Lodi AI.
[10:12] helps people
[10:12] find unauthorized uses of their likeness
or voice online and get it taken
[10:16] of course, AOC,
[10:17] she's personally connected
to this as well,
[10:18] since she's been a victim of
AI generated deepfakes for years
[10:21] and in fact, Hilton pointed out
[10:22] that more than half
[10:23] of the women in Congress
have sexual deepfakes of them online right
[10:26] and while this issue is yes,
particularly relevant to public figures,
[10:28] these disgusting deepfakes are also a
very big issue in middle schools and high
[10:32] and actually during this press conference,
they also had teen deepfake
[10:35] victim Ellison Berry
[10:36] speaking out about her experience
with this, which happened
[10:38] when she was just 14 years
in a matter of seconds.
[10:41] My sense of security disappeared.
[10:43] Embarrassment, shame, and isolation
consumed me.
[10:47] This experience follows me into every day
parts of my life.
[10:52] I withdrew from activities.
[10:54] I struggled academically
and I became increasingly isolated.
[10:58] it's a seemingly, you know,
[10:59] everyone can agree
this is wildly disturbing
[11:01] and people should not be getting away with
and there are people
[11:03] that are all over the political spectrum
who are for this
[11:05] whether whether it be the late Lindsey
Graham or Josh Hawley or senators like Amy
[11:09] there were some of the original
[11:10] and you even had open
AI endorsing the bill
[11:12] back in June with the company's chief
global affairs officer
[11:14] pushing for the House to
then which then brings us to, well,
[11:17] why the hell has the House not passed
what could possibly be holding it
[11:20] and there you would speaker Mike Johnson
telling reporters in September
[11:23] that the Defiance Act is good policy,
but the House hadn't built consensus
[11:27] the really
it seems like there's more to the that
[11:29] and that's for a number of reasons,
including,
[11:30] according to one report from July,
[11:31] you had certain Republicans
not feeling enthusiastic about it
[11:34] specifically
because of its connection to AOC.
[11:36] They or they seemingly
did not want to look like they handed her
[11:38] a win ahead of the which is fucking insane
and disgusting in its even
[11:42] but even with this delay, right, Hilton,
AOC and Lee, they're not and in addition
[11:46] to their press conference,
[11:47] these three also appeared on Fox
News to talk about and and that's actually
[11:50] kind of a huge thing because AOC
has not been on the network since
[11:53] but during that interview,
you had host John Roberts questioning
[11:56] if anything's really going to get done
these next two years,
[11:58] including there going to be more
bipartisan cooperation?
[12:02] Is it going to be investigation,
investigation, investigation?
[12:05] Will anything get done
for the American people?
[12:07] Well, you know, we have the choice.
[12:09] We have the option right now
to make a difference.
[12:12] And we can set this tone.
[12:14] My hope is that we can set it, set
that tone starting right now.
[12:18] And if we can start focusing
on the things that bring us together,
[12:21] if we can pass this bill
[12:23] instead of waiting for the next Congress,
let's do it before December.
[12:27] the wall. So given, you know,
[12:28] the midterms just happened,
there's been a massive blue wave.
[12:31] People are starting
to look to 2028 with this.
[12:33] You had some people going,
it feels interesting that AOC is making
[12:36] a super rare appearance on Right saying
she's speaking on a very agreeable issue.
[12:40] She's talking about the importance
of bipartisanship and getting stuff and so
[12:43] and so good people taking this
and moving it into the issue.
[12:46] Running for president in 2028
right, right.
[12:48] Writing on that front, earlier
this month, you had progressives
[12:50] launching ready for AOC,
[12:51] a political organization
centered around encouraging her
[12:53] to run and demonstrating the sport
she already Right, right.
[12:56] Well, she said she's making that decision,
right. What comes next?
[12:58] Privately,
you also had New York City's DSA chapter
[13:01] urging her and notably in this interview,
Roberts asks her what seems to be
[13:05] now the obligatory question.
[13:06] And her answer has been getting a lot
Just before we go, 2028 is coming up.
[13:09] The DSA wants you to be their candidate.
[13:12] You've got to decide soon
if you're good to go.
[13:13] I mean, my focus is on doing
what's best for people.
[13:16] I'm less about the horse race.
[13:17] You know, these elections just happen.
[13:18] Let's let's get some results
for people first
[13:20] and then we can talk about elections
later.
[13:22] You got to make a decision by February.
March. That's just around the corner.
[13:25] That's right.
[13:26] and so.
[13:26] With that, you had some saying, okay,
[13:27] with the way she said
it, the big smile, people going, okay,
[13:30] that feels like political speak for I'm
definitely running.
[13:32] one. Yes, we'll see what the hell
this field is going to look like
[13:35] on both sides very And also to let's hope
that it does not distract from
[13:39] what is very important here.
[13:40] And that is passing the Defiance
then there's even more we got to dive into
[13:44] in just a minute
after a quick break with our sponsor.
[13:46] it's a quick shout out to today's sponsor
but less boutique
[13:48] they're giving away free rose toys
to every single one of you.
[13:51] Plus early access to Black Friday deals
with up to 80% off everything.
[13:54] yeah. 80% off.
[13:55] And everyone who signs up at BB
vibes.com/defranco win something, right?
[13:59] That's the
[13:59] for partnering with Bellezza Boutique
several times over the past few months
[14:02] it is clear you guys have been loving
and so when they reached out again,
[14:04] saying yes was a no right.
[14:05] They built a comprehensive catalog
of wellness products for everybody.
[14:08] It doesn't matter who you are
or what you're into.
[14:10] They've got something designed with you
[14:11] in what I like about Bellezza
Boutique is the intentionality, right?
[14:13] Everything's body
[14:14] safe, thoughtfully designed
and built to be not about extremes.
[14:17] It's about people
feeling comfortable on their own
[14:19] and whether this is for you
or a very specific person in your life.
[14:21] There's zero judgment
and of course, we had hook
[14:23] you all up with their top selling product,
the Rose suction
[14:25] roses to everyone that places in order.
[14:27] Every single one of you wins.
[14:28] A rose retails for 99 bucks,
but you get it So just click that
[14:31] link in the description
or head to be VI bes.com/defra nco.
[14:37] That's bs.com/rain Or just scan
the QR code and get hooked up today.
[14:44] But then diving back into the news,
but staying with gaming,
[14:46] the US Senate just had its first ever
hearing on Roblox safety.
[14:50] you've got lawmakers on both sides
gunning for the platform.
[14:52] because Roblox, among other things,
they are currently facing
[14:54] nearly 200 lawsuits from families
who allege that
[14:56] the platform allowed predators
to groom, extort and exploit children.
[14:59] back in August,
you had the Senate Judiciary Subcommittee
[15:01] on Crime and Counterterrorism launching
an investigation into child sexual abuse
[15:04] on the platform led by Republican
Josh Hawley and Democrat Dick Durbin.
[15:08] and so then with all that,
they just held this historic hearing
[15:10] as part of that probe, right,
[15:11] as well as to introduce a new bill
that would let families and children harm
[15:14] by tech products,
take their case to public court
[15:16] instead of being forced
to settle their claims
[15:17] privately and arbitration, as is currently
outlined under the terms and service.
[15:21] but also of course they aren't
The same is true for many companies.
[15:23] When you agree to terms and services,
you're agreeing
[15:25] to settle any future harms and arbitration
like that little box that we all check
[15:29] without reading pages of incomprehensible
legal ease.
[15:32] That's happening a lot of the And so while
this bill specifically targets
[15:35] Roblox, it would also go way beyond
just this one platform across the board.
[15:38] You had senators on both sides
and the witnesses
[15:39] who testified before the panel
absolutely tearing into roadblocks,
[15:42] accusing the platform of prioritizing
profits and engagement over child safety
[15:46] and then using forced arbitration
to silence victims
[15:48] and prevent them
from receiving proper justice.
[15:50] According to company data, nearly
[15:51] three quarters of the platform's 144
million active users are minors.
[15:56] and of those, nearly half
are younger than 13 years
[15:58] and so in his opening statement,
you had Holly arguing
[16:00] that the platform's dependance on minors
[16:02] has driven it to implement policies
that hurt those key users.
[16:05] your children are on Roblox,
they are being exposed, in all likelihood
[16:08] to sexual predators, to sexually obscene
material, to sexually exploitative
[16:13] content left, right and center.
[16:17] The company is worth $33 billion.
[16:21] The company CEO is worth $3.3
[16:24] billion on his own.
[16:27] And the sad fact of the matter is,
is that much of that money
[16:30] and many of those profits
have come from exposing children.
[16:34] And I do mean children five, six, seven,
[16:38] eight, nine, ten years old
to sexually obscene material.
[16:42] And the worst part of it is, is that after
[16:44] Roblox does this and they know
what's going on on their platform,
[16:47] after they do it, they force these same
child victims into arbitration, Why?
[16:53] For money,
[16:54] an enormously profitable company
with huge revenues and implementing
[16:58] safety measures that would make it harder
for predators to contact kids,
[17:03] threatens their user count
and therefore their revenues.
[17:07] and you then also had that echoed
by the four witnesses who testified
[17:09] before the committee, which included
two experts and two young men
[17:12] who were both survivors of sexual abuse
on Roblox. right.
[17:14] One of the men,
who was identified as Woody
[17:16] Doerr, claimed that he was groomed
and then sexually assaulted by a man
[17:18] that he met on Roblox when he was 11 years
and then the other is Michael Schlep,
[17:22] who's actually a major content creator
here on Right.
[17:24] With him
running a channel that exposes alleged
[17:26] Roblox child predators and criticizing
the platform for child safety failures
[17:29] after his own experience of
[17:30] And that's super relevant here,
[17:31] because you had schlep arguing
that his current work proves
[17:34] that the platform
is not doing enough to address
[17:36] sexual can tell you
someone who created decoy accounts,
[17:39] it was unbelievably easy for child
predators to reach out.
[17:43] You know, I was able to find games
where child predators
[17:47] would message you on Roblox within
seconds.
[17:50] Roblox is very aware of some of these hubs
and hotspots on the platform,
[17:55] but weren't taking action.
[17:57] So this goes far beyond just,
you know, allowing them to exist.
[18:01] It's knowing you
then end up going on to claim
[18:03] that Roblox actively tried to censor him
when he brought the issue
[18:06] I begged them
for a private reporting line.
[18:09] I mailed physical binders
to their headquarters,
[18:12] and even offered to sign a contract
to help them for free.
[18:16] Instead, I
[18:18] received a cease and desist letter
from Roblox,
[18:22] terminating my accounts
and threatening to sue me then
[18:25] and you then had Woody do making a similar
see them as lazy.
[18:29] If I'm being honest.
[18:30] They have so much money
to dump into their safety programs
[18:33] and protecting children,
and they've just refused
[18:36] the fact that this thing
has happened to me over 15 years ago,
[18:39] when I'm still hearing of cases
happening very similar to myself.
[18:43] It just goes to show
[18:43] that they haven't put really any effort
into keeping our kids safe.
[18:47] and at that point,
you basically everyone on that panel
[18:49] arguing that the changes
that Roblox is implemented
[18:51] in the face of these lawsuits,
it does not go far enough Right.
[18:54] The platform claims that it's implemented
[18:55] a handful of child safety measures,
many of which were focused on age
[18:58] you had Corey James, senior legal counsel
at the National Center on Sexual
[19:01] Exploitation, accusing Roblox of failing
to make meaningful changes.
[19:04] saying researchers at the center,
they were able to create accounts posing
[19:07] as five
[19:07] year olds with no parental consent or age
verification, as well as freely interact
[19:11] with stranger and access experiences
involving dating, romance and right.
[19:15] She also said that predators
can get around age
[19:17] gates and chat restrictions,
[19:18] while arguing that the company hasn't
enacted effective parental A safety system
[19:22] that requires parents to be
cybersecurity experts
[19:25] does not adequately protect children.
[19:30] Parents cannot use
[19:31] safeguards that are confusing
or buried in the settings,
[19:35] and parental controls cannot be
a substitute for platform responsibility.
[19:40] Roblox has scratched the surface
[19:43] and done the bare minimum
to say that they're protecting children.
[19:47] But that's
because the world is watching right now.
[19:50] But what happens when the world isn't
watching, right.
[19:53] And we know what's going to happen,
because for the past ten years,
[19:56] they did nothing.
[19:57] Nothing
[19:59] because there was no consequence.
[20:01] Right.
[20:01] On that last note,
you had all the witnesses urging Congress
[20:03] to hold Roblox accountable
by passing the bill,
[20:06] allowing families to take their cases
against Roblox to public
[20:08] arguing that Roblox,
they're never going to implement
[20:10] adequate changes on its own,
and the only way that it will take
[20:13] action is by facing the consequences
of actually being held liable
[20:16] and having its dirty laundry aired in that
and with that, you would.
[20:19] Miriam Gillis, for example,
a law professor at northwestern
[20:21] and one of the top experts
[20:22] on forest arbitration, explaining it,
the only way they can actually be held
[20:25] accountable is public accountability,
that that can change
[20:28] noting that
[20:29] when Roblox is made changes in the past,
it is because of the public courts produce
[20:33] a public record and arbitration
is designed to do the exact opposite.
[20:37] Right.
[20:37] It's designed, as you said, to muzzle to
to make everything as secret as possible.
[20:42] And public accountability produces
reform, right.
[20:45] We've seen a time and time with
[20:46] with Roblox pass one of these bills
and just get rid of forced arbitration.
[20:51] You will be amazed by how quickly
[20:53] the company will change its behavior
once it is sued in public court.
[20:57] Now, as far as how you had Roblox
responding to this, you had a spokesperson
[21:00] defending the company's record,
saying that safety has always been central
[21:03] to the platform,
claiming that it's working on
[21:04] enhancing its capabilities
and arguing that,
[21:06] A legal position about arbitration
is not a measure of a company
[21:09] safety record, and a hearing built around
it fails to advance
[21:12] but but there you also had Holly hitting
back, noting that senators asked Roblox,
[21:15] the CEO, to testify at the hearing,
but he refused,
[21:18] And the fact that he's not here today
speaks volumes.
[21:22] He may think he's silent,
but in fact, he's testifying.
[21:26] And what he's testifying to
is his commitment to money over people,
[21:29] to profits, over anything,
[21:33] to exploitation, over what is right.
[21:34] But then also Roblox
is really just the tip of the iceberg
[21:37] when it comes to tech platforms
and their users preying on children.
[21:40] because, you know, another one's meta
and the internal documents
[21:42] that we just got from them,
they are so revealing.
[21:43] They should probably just be labeled intro
to corporate Psychopathy 101.
[21:47] and for some context here.
[21:47] What we're talking about is a feature
[21:48] that meta launched on Instagram
last year called School Communities.
[21:51] basically local networks
where students can get verified
[21:54] with their school banner on their profile,
access a directory with other students
[21:57] from the same school, and post notes and
stories that only school members can see.
[22:00] with meta suggesting
that kids can stay informed on stuff like,
[22:02] for example,
[22:02] basketball
tryouts and school administrators
[22:04] can monitor their activity
and report any abuse so to the public.
[22:07] They called it a school partnership
program, claiming it.
[22:09] The purpose was to protect kids
from cyberbullying,
[22:11] and internally they called it
Project Gryffindor.
[22:13] And the real purpose was clear
make a ton of money
[22:16] And they do it by getting as many kids
onto their platforms as they could,
[22:19] attracting them at younger ages
and keeping them there longer. right.
[22:22] And explicitly in a 2024 presentation,
meta said integrating with schools
[22:25] was meant to increase user acquisition,
friending and invites.
[22:28] and then you also had another presentation
[22:29] the year before that where meta said that
the program would give teens a new reason
[22:32] to join slash,
find more value in Instagram,
[22:35] a matching our current strategy
[22:36] of relying on power user teens to get less
active friends onto IG
[22:40] and may not be effective
if there are full communities of teens
[22:42] that have not yet joined IG,
or to translate it,
[22:44] just rely on kids to peer pressure
each other into joining.
[22:47] That's not enough.
[22:48] We need pressure on a school wide level
[22:50] to crack open
these remaining friend groups.
[22:52] that's not to say
[22:52] that meta has given up the strategy
of using some kids to influence others,
[22:56] you would one document noting
that teens strongly influence pre-teens
[22:59] understanding of what
and how frequently to share on Instagram.
[23:01] so if you establish a pattern
for one grade of students,
[23:03] they model
that behavior to the next generation.
[23:06] And that's important because Quote
tweens aged 10 to 12 are special.
[23:09] Adding people who join Facebook as
[23:11] tweens have the highest long term
retention out of all age groups.
[23:14] which, just to be clear, appears
to contradict Meta's own policy Right.
[23:18] Officially, publicly.
[23:19] The minimum age
you need to be to sign up for Facebook
[23:20] and Instagram is 13 years old.
[23:22] Yet here they seem to be targeting kids
even younger.
[23:24] and also speaking of contradictions, meta
has repeatedly insisted, quote,
[23:28] we don't want social media
to be a distraction from school.
[23:30] it, according to a brief
in one of the lawsuits against meta,
[23:32] an employee laid out their engagement
goals in 2015, writing,
[23:36] one of the things we need to optimize for
is sneaking a look at your phone
[23:39] under your desk
in the middle of chemistry. Smiley face.
[23:42] And apparently
those were not just some empty words,
[23:44] because the same brief says
that meta began harvesting data
[23:46] to be able to tell
when users were at school,
[23:48] and then they allegedly targeted students
in specific schools
[23:51] with push notifications
that they called school blasts
[23:54] the aim being to, quote tip schools
from inactive to active via network
[23:57] effects and incrementally
increase teen engagement.
[23:59] and so with all these embarrassing
exposing documents getting dumped,
[24:03] you had the executive director
of the Tech Oversight Project telling NPR,
[24:06] his latest attempt at Trojan Horse
their tech into the school day
[24:09] shows the business strategy remains
the same.
[24:11] Maximize
their profits at our kids expense.
[24:13] apparently it's working
because when they expanded Project
[24:15] Gryffindor in September,
meta said almost 17,000 schools
[24:18] had signed up for the program.
[24:19] now with that, the companies defense
[24:21] is that it gives educators a way to report
concerning activity to meta
[24:24] and that school reports will get
prioritized.
[24:26] you've got online
safety experts tell NPR that the program
[24:28] could actually put students
in more danger,
[24:30] not just with mental health risks,
but with predators.
[24:33] Because all those students go through
third party verification before
[24:35] joining a school community,
the accounts get hacked all the time.
[24:38] mean, just this year,
there was a case where someone hijacked
[24:40] hundreds of young people's
[24:41] social media accounts,
including on Instagram and Snapchat,
[24:43] and then threatened to release
sensitive photos.
[24:45] and you've got dozens of documented
instances of young folks
[24:47] taking their own lives
that are being extorted just in the past
[24:50] several years.
[24:50] and so, as one expert
put it, once an account is embedded
[24:53] within a school
and has an active school profile,
[24:55] they can see all sorts of things
like directories
[24:57] of the different clubs,
different groups on campus.
[24:59] And that's a extortionists dream
plus even just knowing which school
[25:03] someone goes to is leverage for predators.
[25:04] And they can threaten to send
sensitive stuff to others at that school.
[25:07] But then also
it makes so much more of this
[25:09] jaw dropping is the timing.
because this program
[25:11] meant to hook schools,
even middle schools up to Instagram.
[25:13] not some old thing that just got revealed.
[25:15] But this was launched
last year, expanded this year,
[25:18] and it's still being rolled out.
[25:19] I guess to say in another way,
[25:20] meta is doing all of this
at the same time that it's losing lawsuit
[25:23] after lawsuit for allegedly trying
to get kids addicted to its platforms.
[25:27] right.
[25:27] In March, a trial jury found that
the company designed them to be addictive.
[25:30] then in August,
you had meta agreeing to a settlement
[25:32] worth up to $17 billion over
similar allegations.
[25:35] and then just yesterday,
a meta shareholder sued Mark Zuckerberg
[25:37] and other executives, claiming
they put profits over child safety
[25:40] and misled investors about the legal risks
stemming from that choice.
[25:43] also right now
[25:44] that is appealing yet another lawsuit
in which a jury found
[25:46] that the company had also misled consumers
about the safety of its platforms
[25:49] and knowingly harmed children.
[25:50] So, yeah, you just pare everything
with these documents
[25:52] that we've now just read,
and it is a horrible look.
[25:55] on the outside, they're gonna continue
saying, hey, happy boys, good times.
[25:58] We just want to help kids stay safe
and get involved in school activities.
[26:01] but on the inside, behind the scenes,
they're like,
[26:03] we got to get these kids hooked
before they go through puberty.
[26:05] So they stay forever and pressure
all their friends to join.
[26:08] then there's a few more things
we got to dive into today in just a minute
[26:11] after a quick break with our sponsor.
[26:13] know, a good pair of boots
has this weird ability
[26:15] to make the rest of your outfit
look like you planned it.
[26:17] that's been my experience
with today's sponsor takeovers.
[26:19] I've been wearing my Cartwrights and Cafe,
and they are just one of those pairs
[26:22] I can throw on with jeans,
chinos, whatever.
[26:24] And suddenly the whole thing looks way
more intentional.
[26:26] I also say the comfort still surprises me
They feel good right away.
[26:29] No dramatic break in period
where my feet had to suffer for fashion.
[26:32] and takeovers are handmade
[26:33] through more than 200 steps
using premium leathers,
[26:35] and you can genuinely feel
the craftsmanship when you put them on.
[26:37] they've got that classic Western look,
but they still feel modern enough
[26:40] that I'm not suddenly expected
to know how to rope something.
[26:42] I'm going to say,
if you are near a takeover store,
[26:44] it is actually worth
checking out in person.
[26:46] they've got complimentary drinks,
reboot shines, expert fittings and custom
[26:49] leather branding.
[26:50] If you want to make the pair
more your own.
[26:52] And if you need something
tougher for work,
[26:53] they've got options with waterproofing,
[26:55] slip resistant outsole, safety
toes and more.
[26:57] whether you want something
sharp for everyday wear or something
[26:59] built to take a beating,
there's a lot to choose from.
[27:01] they click the link in my description,
[27:02] or scan the QR code
to find your next pair of takeovers.
[27:05] that's takeovers with an S.
[27:06] and then Devin right back into the news.
[27:07] We've got a few more things
we got to talk about today,
[27:09] starting with Mary Portola,
Because Mary, she's kicking Dan Sullivan
[27:12] out of his Senate seat
to become the first Alaska Native woman,
[27:15] and one of the only two indigenous women
ever elected to the Senate.
[27:18] of course, key thing
connected to this blue wave.
[27:20] She is the first Democrat
in that state to take the seat since 2008.
[27:23] and as long as it's been,
[27:25] it felt even longer
waiting for them to count these votes.
[27:29] because they have a pretty generous window
for mail in ballots.
[27:31] And a lot of rural communities
count ballots by hand as well.
[27:34] So things took longer
but yeah, now that the votes are in,
[27:36] they have brought the blue tsunami,
the blue to a grand total
[27:40] of nine new seats in the Senate,
giving Democrats a 56 to 44 edge.
[27:45] and it was a pretty hard fought race
with one of the biggest public battles
[27:47] probably being the back and forth
about whether the Democrats
[27:49] purposely threw in a second Dan Sullivan
and a guy named Gerald.
[27:53] The spoiler the one Bitola
and the rest of the party denied it.
[27:56] And two reports say that Republicans
also spent over $1.6 million
[28:00] to push their own spoiler
candidates in the primaries, though
[28:02] they never made it
onto the general election so
[28:04] and so the whole situation
has been all over the place. Right.
[28:05] The Justice Department
also sued last month
[28:07] the block,
the certification of the election results.
[28:09] If the incumbent, Sullivan,
lost by fewer votes than the other
[28:12] But then that got tossed out by a district
judge before Election Day even
[28:15] and then while that was going
on, Republicans were calling
[28:17] in all the heavy hitters
to rally for though
[28:19] a lot of people actually thought
that would that
[28:21] and that in part because reports say
that Alaska is super sensitive to price
[28:24] more with more than 80% of its communities
[28:25] importing and transporting
groceries and fuels,
[28:27] since they're not connected
to the national road
[28:29] and so with all of the complaints
[28:30] we've seen about affordability,
which Trump, of course, called a hoax,
[28:33] calling on people like Trump and JD Vance,
it seemed to be a But still, with that,
[28:37] you had Republicans
pulling out all the stops,
[28:39] with political experts saying
[28:40] just stuck to a basic language of
[28:42] the elites or benefiting themselves
and leaving the rest of us hung out to
[28:45] and leaned a lot on issues
like affordability,
[28:48] corruption and corporate and importantly,
both to understand
[28:50] her getting elected as well
as how she is going to act as a senator.
[28:54] She is known for being pretty fact,
and in fact,
[28:56] she's not afraid to go against her party
at times sporting things
[28:58] like gun ownership and fossil fuel
[28:59] and apparently, that helped regain
[29:01] some key supporters in the state
on both sides of the and
[29:03] and so now it all appears
to have worked out.
[29:04] But they're saying that Alaskans
have voted for change.
[29:06] And adding that together,
[29:07] we're going to put an end
to the era of self-serving politicians
[29:10] lining their own pockets at your And
adding together, we're going to put Alaska
[29:14] but then also from that we got to talk
about the Nvidia news because Nvidia
[29:17] they just blew the projections
for their Q3 earnings out of the water.
[29:21] and that's even as they're picking up
the pieces from losing former CEO Jensen
[29:25] they had record breaking sales
with $115.8 billion in revenue,
[29:28] which is 6.3% higher than analysts
predicted and 103% higher
[29:32] than what
they were seeing last year at this time.
[29:34] and their net income also shocked analysts
coming in at $65.3 billion.
[29:38] also data center
revenue up 110% from last year as well,
[29:41] for a total of $107.6 billion in sales.
[29:44] while these are great numbers,
I'll also note that they still haven't
[29:47] seen that kind of boost in their market
value since Huang's resignation.
[29:50] you've had analysts saying
we're at a point of peak uncertainty
[29:53] because investors
still don't know what anybody has long
[29:55] term leadership will look like.
[29:56] especially because,
[29:57] well, yesterday he made a statement
talking about all the calls
[29:59] he's heard in support of him
getting his job back.
[30:01] And, hey,
[30:02] he'd be honored to step back up
if the board of directors
[30:04] thought it was in the best
interest of the company,
[30:05] according to reports,
the chair of the board is flat out
[30:07] saying
that they are not considering reinstating
[30:09] and there's an argument
that with the numbers moving
[30:11] the way they are now without him,
and That potentially takes away
[30:14] the case
for Wang to come the likely there.
[30:16] We won't have much concrete evidence
on that front until the next earnings
[30:20] and even
[30:20] that doesn't take into consideration
the concerns about an alleged Chinese spy.
[30:24] and also say we're now getting reports
that at least one other big name CEO
[30:28] who's been approached
to take over the company,
[30:29] which sounds even more like they're moving
away from the idea of having Hwang Bang.
[30:33] but for now, we'll have to wait
to see how this plays then finally today.
[30:35] Hakeem
Jeffries is now officially one floor
[30:37] vote away from making history
as the first black speaker of the House.
[30:41] but history side.
[30:42] You're seeing a lot of voters
mad that the Democrats
[30:44] they're not shaking things up enough
today.
[30:46] House Democrats held their closed door
leadership elections
[30:48] and overwhelmingly nominated
Hakeem Jeffries
[30:50] to be the next speaker of the House
by a vote of 251 to 11 with zero
[30:54] and if he wins as expected the full floor
vote on January 3rd.
[30:58] That's then and then right behind him
you have Catherine Clark and Pete Aguilar
[31:00] also cruising in unopposed
for majority leader and and.
[31:03] Well, and while this was expected,
not everyone in the party is thrilled
[31:05] about keeping the band back with or with
[31:06] especially the for this left
wing parts of the party
[31:08] increasingly demanding progressive reforms
like Medicare for
[31:11] and in general,
you have them arguing that voters
[31:12] elected them for a real shakeup
on health care money in politics
[31:15] and foreign policy,
not to just run it back
[31:17] but the Democratic majority
that's coming into the House, it's
[31:19] so big that Jeffries can probably weather
[31:21] some dissent and be over
but over in the Senate, things are way
[31:24] got because you've got Senator Chris
Van Hollen mounting the first contested
[31:27] challenge against Chuck Schumer
in over a and Van
[31:29] Hollen has been positioning himself
[31:30] as a populist underdog,
although how progressive
[31:33] he actually is, that remains
to be fully seen right
[31:35] and assuming that he can win the vote
on December party's right.
[31:37] But the party's establishment,
they appear to be clearly betting that
[31:39] a unified, experienced front in their eyes
[31:41] is the smartest way
to take on the white House in question.
[31:43] But there's a question of will
that backfire in voters. Right voters.
[31:46] They clearly came into the midterms
to rebuke Trump and demand some serious
[31:49] and even if you have the old guard saying
they're open to some of the new stuff,
[31:53] will they for now.
[31:53] But for now,
[31:54] we need to see what happens with the votes
first, especially
[31:56] And then and then come
[31:57] January, people are going to be waiting
to see what energy Democrats
[32:00] handshakes and stern looks or belt
But that my friends, you beautiful
[32:03] bastards, is the end of your Wednesday
Philip DeFranco show.
[32:06] course, as always,
I got more for you to watch right here.
[32:08] If you're not 100% filled no matter what
you do, let me say thank you for watching.
[32:11] Like and share and be and subscribe
to these daily dives into the news.
[32:14] Because my name is Philip DeFranco.
[32:16] You've just been filled in.
[32:17] I love your faces
and I'll see you right back here tomorrow.
YouTube captions